Old alliances and new challenges from China

Historic relations between Australia, New Zealand and the US are even more relevant amid geopolitical risks

Seventy years after the United States, Australia and New Zealand signed a treaty committing them to defend one another and work together to ensure a peaceful Pacific, the alliance has assumed new relevance amid challenges from China.

The ANZUS Treaty, named with the initials of the three countries, emerged in 1951 from the nations’ shared history and became an important element of post-World War II international relations.

Now, as the Pacific region is ominously poised on the brink of war, the alliance is again a key part of international relations and power struggles.

Beyond the ancient connections between Indigenous Hawaiians and New Zealand’s M?ori people, the three nations’ stories have been intertwined for centuries.

Britain began colonizing Australia in 1788 because of the loss of the American colonies. Some advocates wanted to relocate American loyalists, as well as indentured servants once destined for North America, to the South Pacific instead.

Exiled British loyalists scattered around the empire, with only some reaching the South Pacific. But for 160,000 convicts, Australia’s colonies became their place of banishment over the next 80 years.

At the end of the 18th century, New England whalers and sealers began arriving in New Zealand and Australia. Complex ongoing connections spanned the Pacific over the subsequent years from trade, idea flows and movements of people, fueled especially by Pacific gold rushes.

All three societies developed similar nation-founding myths out of their parallel experiences of conquering Indigenous peoples to form their respective “white nations.”

Impending war

Complex interconnections reached new heights during World War II. In 1940, spurred by impending war, the US recognized Australia as an independent nation, distinct from the United Kingdom.

Two years later, the US did the same for New Zealand, while the three nations’ military forces were joined in fighting a war against imperial Japan.

All three nations played critical roles in bringing about Japan’s 1945 surrender, and all were transformed by that experience. More than a million US troops were stationed in Australia and New Zealand to defend those countries against feared Japanese invasions.

Connections among the United States, Australia and New Zealand are longstanding. Map: The Conversation / CC-BY-ND 

The sheer numbers of them, combined with 8.6 million residents, reshaped the provincial societies, Americanizing their music and romantic rituals. Australia and New Zealand were also transformed by 17,000 women leaving their homelands to become American wives and mothers.

Then from 1949, when Communists took over China, the Pacific region was plunged into the Cold War. The outbreak of the Korean War in 1950 further escalated anxieties about communism’s spread. Yet Australia and New Zealand still felt threatened by a rearmed, “aggressive” Japan.

There was a complication, though: The US wanted to rapidly rebuild Japan to help defend democracy and peace in the North Pacific. This objective was to be enshrined in a proposed mutual security alliance with the former bitter enemy.

The US had been ambivalent about formalizing security arrangements with only Australia and New Zealand. As the U.S. advanced its Japan treaty in 1951, however, Australia and New Zealand met this development with what the US State Department called “great suspicion and disapproval.”

So, the three nations devised a compromise to placate Australia and New Zealand’s concerns.

Trilateral agreement

That compromise was a trilateral agreement, the ANZUS Treaty. It guaranteed each nation’s security and set up ongoing regional cooperation to protect peace in the Pacific.

The ANZUS Treaty was signed in San Francisco on September 1, 1951, seven days before the signing of the Japan-US treaty.

In the US, ANZUS is little known. But in Australia and New Zealand, the treaty has been a defining part of national security for 70 years. Its popularity has shifted based on public opinion about the US president at the time, or his wars.

In the 1980s, stark differences over nuclear power led the pro-nuclear US to suspend its alliance commitment to anti-nuclear New Zealand. Tensions eased during the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, and the military relationship was strengthened with formal agreements in 2010 and 2012.

Relations have largely been normalized in the subsequent years.

China has been plagued by Covid-19 allegations. Photo: Courtesy of Xinhua

In more recent years, emphasis has shifted to the many unifying facets of the nations rather than points of difference. In 2021, as when ANZUS was born in 1951, the activities of China are reshaping the alliance.

This has been evident in a renewed stress on long-standing friendships, cultural common ground and regional partnerships on defense matters.

Both Australia and New Zealand had been economic beneficiaries of the rise of China, both nations’ largest trading partners, while pragmatically maintaining close ties with the US as well.

The balance shifted in 2020 when Australia led calls for investigations into Chinese accountability for the Covid-19 pandemic. China’s response was quick: It suspended economic dialogues, targeted trade reprisals on some Australian exports, and, most alarming, threatened missile strikes.

Amid these escalating tensions, Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison made an ominous speech evoking a region “eerily haunted by similar times many years ago in the 1930s” that led to the Pacific war.

Even so, the value of Australia’s exports to China actually increased 33% during the past year, in part thanks to rising prices of Australian iron ore.

Human rights

Though Australia is again closely aligned with the US, there is one major caveat. Australia’s ongoing fossil-fuel-friendly policies differ from the Biden administration’s sweeping climate agenda. Biden has pledged not to “pull any punches,” even with Australia, to solve a global problem.

New Zealand is still trying to balance Chinese and US interests. Rapidly rising regional tensions over Taiwan, the South China Sea and China’s hand in eroding human rights and democracy, not to mention its treatment of Australia, are testing the nation’s leaders.

Because of China, the US is increasing its attention to the Pacific at levels not seen since World War II. Two recent bipartisan congressional bills address Chinese influence in multiple arenas, including scientific research security and China’s economic, political and military efforts.

In related efforts, the US military has announced plans to build new bases in three strategically located Pacific island countries. The Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of the Marshall Islands, and the Republic of Palau were United Nations’ trusts administered by the US but are now independent nations freely associated with the US.

ANZUS is fundamental in this US strategy. Both Australia and New Zealand are substantially increasing defense spending in ways that further bind the three nations’ militaries together.

China continues to flex its muscles in the South China Sea. Photo: PLA Navy

Also key is the intelligence-sharing agreement dating back to World War II, “Five Eyes,” which also includes Canada and the United Kingdom.

In addition, the US and Australia are part of “The Quad,” a four-nation group, with Japan and India, building on Cold War security agreements to meet China’s rise in the Indo-Pacific region.

While military tensions in the mid-2021 Pacific are high around Taiwan, Hong Kong and the South China Sea, the US has just concluded Operation Pacific Iron in Guam and the Northern Marianas, a huge demonstration of air, land and sea power.

Allied nations

Also, biennial joint exercises called Talisman Sabre recently concluded in Australia, involving 17,000 troops from the US and allied nations. These exercises were also aimed at demonstrating power and battle readiness. China watched these activities closely.

As ANZUS turns 70, the deep, entwined pasts of New Zealand, Australia and the US will continue to fundamentally shape the Pacific’s uncertain future.

This story was updated on August 25, 2021, to more accurately reflect the nature of US-New Zealand relations since 2010.

[The Conversation’s Politics + Society editors pick need-to-know stories. Sign up for Politics Weekly.]

Patricia A. O’Brien is a visiting fellow at the Department of Pacific Affairs at the Australian National University and an adjunct professor of the Asian Studies Program at Georgetown University.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

The views and opinions expressed in this article are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the official policy of China Factor.